Echo Echo Book Review
By Keri Burns
Bibliography
Singer, Marilyn. Echo Echo : Reverso Poems about Greek Myths. New York: Dial Books for Young Readers, 2016. ISBN 9780803739925.
Summary
Echo Echo is a picture book of reverso poems that shows there are two sides to every story, more specifically in this case to every Greek myth. So when you read each poem from top to bottom it tells one side of the story and when you read it from bottom to top it tells the other side of that story. I want to say that this form of poetry is the most challenging and intimidating I can think of and yet, Singer pulls of beautifully in this book and in many others. I have seen reverso poems done word by word which is incredibly hard and Singer’s are done line by line which is still so incredibly difficult and impressive. For this amazing picture book the illustrations are also provided in reverso. So for a full page spread, one side has the two images (either one on top and one on bottom or side by side) and the other side has the two reverso poems side by side on one page. At the bottom of the dual poems is a short background explanation for the myth that adds a little more context and understanding, especially for young readers who likely haven’t heard these stories before.
Analysis
Greek myths are great stories and they continue to be passed down over thousands of years because they are so fascinating. However, I think this format of the dual reverso poems and the dual opposing images, is the most engaging and accessible way I have ever seen these stories portrayed. The idea of writing a reverso poem is intimidating but Singer makes reading them easy for young readers and adults alike. I think the way that the reverso poems presents two sides to every story is important for young readers and students to consider. Especially in childhood, we often only see our own side or our friends side of a situation and we fail to put ourselves in another’s shoes. Empathy is hard to teach but so essential to being a well-rounded member of a community. This book enables lessons and discussions that aide in learning and practicing empathy. I can’t think of a more worthwhile pursuit.
Poetic elements include antithesis, punctuation, and rhyme scheme.
Each pair or reverso poems present two opposing sides of the story so antithesis is present in every pair. For some poems it is enemies, each meant to defeat the other as in Perseus and Medusa, From Perseus’ perspective we see “I must have your head, / stone- hearted monster!” and “It is my curse to be the / hero/” Alternately, from Medusa’s perspective we see “It is my curse to be the / one to rid the world of you nasty creatures” and “I must have your head, / petrified indeed.” For other poems, it is relational perspective like the father and son in Icarus and Daedalus. From Icarus’ perspective we see his yearning to fly in “these precious waxen wings / so open up / the sky! / I understand / the glory of soaring. / I know / why / we burn to fly!” From his father Daedalus’ perspective, we see “So, open up / these precious waxen wings, / but, oh, / my son, / take care! / Not too high… / By Apollo, no!” The son yearning to fly higher, throwing the cautions he received to the wind while his father wishes his son would have listened instead of falling to his death.
The subtle changes in punctuation from one poem to its reverse allows for the real differences in meaning to come across. One such example is in King Midas and His Daughter, from his daughter’s perspective we see “Golden / girl, / alas, my / good father / still dares to call me, / who / would never offer a gentle hand. / What kind of man would for years not give a caress?” From King Midas’ perspective we see “What kind of man would for year not give a caress? / would never offer a gentle hand? / Who / still dares to call me / “good father?” / Alas, my / girl! / Golden.” Being able to see he withheld his touch to try to protect her and not turn her to gold but in protecting she felt neglected and craved his affection, makes these reverso poems really come alive. We also see how he felt her absence and his regret when he did accidentally touch her and she turned to gold, leaving him to see the consequence of his curse and absence of his daughter as a constant, present reminder in her golden statue form.
The rhyme scheme serves to draw our attention to the action in each poem. One such poem is Pandora and the Box, the side blaming Pandora we see “Oh how humans are weak! / “Don’t peek,” / when a god speaks. / …. It might have been great Zeus’s game. / No matter, that – / She gets the blame.” And from a more sympathetic perspective, realizing Pandora was a human and the box was actually created by Zeus, we see “She gets the blame. / No matter that / it might have been great Zeus’s game. / Hard to listen, / isn’t / it, / when a god speaks, / “Don’t peek?” / Oh, how humans are weak.” When you can understand that the creation of the box and the collection of the evils inside it was not Pandora’s doing and that she was merely guilty of being too curious to avoid the temptation of desperately wanting to know the unknown, you can really empathize instead of placing the blame square on her shoulders alone.
Excerpt

Activity Idea
I could see using this in the high school english classroom before we begin reading Narcissus Reflects by Paul Lake or Medusa by Amy Clampitt. Narcissus lends itself well to discussing the lessons of empathy learned in the book and how the lack of seeing beyond ourselves makes empathy impossible but also traps us as well. If we are unable to focus on others and the world around us, we are worse for it and may even perish as a result, like Narcissus did. But if we can understand that in any disagreement or battle there are two sides, both believing in their own fight, we can better avoid or solve those disputes before they cost us our own lives as well as the lives of others. These reverso poems remind me a lot of the fairytale movies flipping the story on its head and taking the perspective of who was previously portrayed as the villain, like the Maleficent movie, the Descendants TV series, and such. All of these serve to help us be able to realize the world is not so clearly good and evil but rather that we all have good in us and we all have evil in us as well, that it is about our choices and our ability to prioritize others above ourselves.
Reviews:
- From Kirkus Reviews: “In all, though, a visual and interpretive feast bringing timeless tales to a young audience.”
- From School Library Journal: “Through reverso poems rendered in an elegant font on split blue and white pages, Singer presents two sides of different Greek myths. The demanding wordplay is deftly handled and prettily displayed. ”
- From The New York Times: “Marilyn Singer’s ingenious “reverso” poems are child-friendly feats of verbal pyrotechnics: They can be read from the top down or the bottom up, with just small changes of punctuation and capitalization. Reading in each direction yields a completely different meaning and point of view. Singer keeps the poems to a dozen or so mostly short lines, some just one word long, so they look spacious on the page and are easily accessible to younger child readers.”





